Sara's Promise Ring

From AEWiki

The Shady Man east of town claims it belonged to his mom...I mean auntie...was stolen, and he will reward you if you return it to him. It's been recovered and is being held in a loot locker by the guards at the east gate. Talk to the officer there who will tell you he needs a receipt from Sara. Go back to town and talk to Sara who is overjoyed, signs the receipt and promises to reward you for its return. Off you go, back to the east gate, click the loot chest and take the ring. Now it's decisions, decisions! Should you return it to the Shady Man or Sara? Let your heart be your guide!

See also Young Maiden - Jealousy Amulet who will also take the ring.